Book Review: This Far: My Story of Love, Loss, and Embracing the Light by Allison Holker
I’ve been an admirer of Allison Holker since her captivating performances on So You Think You Can Dance. I remember being utterly crushed when she was voted off in Season 2, and it felt like a personal loss. So when I picked up This Far: My Story of Love, Loss, and Embracing the Light, I did so both as an enthusiast and a parent who has encountered the painful reality of grief, especially linked to suicide. This book sparked my curiosity not just because of my love for her artistry, but also due to the controversial responses it has ignited—an interesting juxtaposition of fervent admiration and intense criticism.
Allison’s narrative unfolds in two distinct acts: the first detailing her life, dreams, and the love she shared with Steven, while the second dives into the aftermath of his tragic decision to end his life. It’s evident that she grapples with profound emotions and seeks to convey strength through her writing. Yet, as someone touched by similar loss, it was difficult to fully appreciate her journey without feeling a sense of unease about her portrayal of Steven’s struggles and the contradictions throughout the memoir.
One of the prominent themes is that of duality—Allison often insists that “both things can be true.” While this notion resonates, it feels slightly at odds with her narrative. For instance, she frequently references the deeply profound conversations she and Steven supposedly had about their future as a family, but then later claims she had “zero interest in deep introspective journeys.” Moments like these left me yearning for a clearer connection among her experiences; more transparency could have enhanced the understanding of her emotions.
Allison’s writing style feels conversational, often mirroring a series of heartfelt but disjointed social media posts. Her intention to maintain authenticity is commendable, yet some parts felt rushed and lacking cohesion. It’s clear she has a unique voice, but the varied vocabulary choices often struck me as a bit forced, leaving me questioning whether she fully grasped the words she chose.
Amidst the criticisms, I appreciated the tender moments she shared with her children—offering them emotional space and support as they navigated their grief. It showcased her commitment to equipping them with the tools they need, even if the method of sharing those experiences sometimes felt flawed. However, I couldn’t shake the worry about whether her children had truly consented to their stories being shared in such a public forum. Their privacy in such vulnerable moments deserves utmost respect.
In concluding my thoughts, I believe This Far will resonate with those working through their own grief and those navigating the complexities of love and loss. It’s a reminder that everyone’s healing journey is personal and nuanced. However, it’s also a cautionary tale about the consequences of sharing trauma on a public platform—something that can be both healing and harmful.
This book impacted me deeply, prompting reflection on my own experiences with loss. While I empathize with Allison’s pain and desire for strength, I hope that in her future works, she finds a balance that honors all facets of her journey and the lives intertwined with hers. If you’re curious about the interplay of grief and resilience, this memoir might be worth exploring, but approach it with an open heart and a discerning mind.
Discover more about This Far: My Story of Love, Loss, and Embracing the Lig… on GoodReads >>