Review: "Roma soy yo: La verdadera historia de Julio César" by Santiago Posteguillo
When I first picked up Roma soy yo: La verdadera historia de Julio César, I was looking forward to a gripping dive into the rich tapestry of Roman history, guided by the keen insight of Santiago Posteguillo, an author who once captivated me with his Scipio Africanus trilogy. However, finishing this latest installment left me with a complex mix of emotions—mostly disappointment and concern.
At its core, Roma soy yo seeks to tell the "true story" of Julius Caesar, but the narrative quickly reveals itself as a fantastical blend of melodrama and inaccuracies. The portrayal of historical figures felt like caricatures, rather than the nuanced characters central to Roman history. While I hoped for a deeper understanding of Caesar and his complex environment, the book instead peddles simplistic archetypes—a noble Julius battling a cartoonish villain in Sulla, whose motivations are reduced to sheer depravity. In a time when historical fiction should illuminate the past, Posteguillo’s rendering feels more akin to a telenovela than a serious endeavor.
The writing style is another point of concern. While Posteguillo has a talent for engaging narratives, his technique in this book often resorts to choppy sentences and over-explanations. It’s as if he has forgotten the art of subtlety. Considering his earlier works, I found myself wondering what happened to the skilled storyteller I once admired. Phrases that should have resonated lost their impact through overly literal translations. Key terms—like "Tribune of the Plebs," which seems simplistic rather than contextual—were rendered ineffectively. This lack of attention to historical nuance stripped the narrative of its authenticity, leaving readers like me frustrated.
But the largest disservice comes from how Posteguillo conflates modern political issues with ancient narratives. In interviews, he has made alarming comparisons between Caesar and contemporary political figures, indirectly trivializing the serious matters faced by nations today. This approach not only overlooks historical context but also appears to exploit current events for sensationalism—a step away from the respectful exploration of history.
For readers who crave a sense of historical accuracy entangled with engaging storytelling, this book might disappoint. However, it could appeal to those looking for a light, dramatic interpretation of Roman history—perhaps more akin to historical fantasy than genuine historical fiction.
In conclusion, my experience with Roma soy yo is bittersweet. While it sparked an emotional response and reflection on how various authors navigate historical narratives, it also served as a reminder of the delicate balance that must be maintained between artistic license and historical integrity. As I emerge from this reading experience, I find myself yearning for the kind of insightful and rich storytelling that respects the complexities of history, something that Posteguillo fell short of delivering this time.
If you’re a die-hard fan of Roman history, you may want to tread lightly here. For others who lean into bold melodrama—maybe for escapism more than authenticity—this book may just find its audience. As for me, I’ll be reconsidering my expectations for future historical fiction with this experience firmly lodged in my mind.
Discover more about Roma soy yo: La verdadera historia de Julio César (Juli… on GoodReads >>