Exploring the Nuances of Life in "Moderation" by the Talented B. M. Hargrove
Sometimes, a book simply catches you off guard, enveloping you in a world you weren’t prepared to love. This was exactly my experience with B. M. Hargrove’s Moderation. From the moment I dove in, I felt as if I were slipping into a warm blanket of nuance and authenticity. It beckoned with themes of content moderation, the underbelly of Silicon Valley’s dystopian reality, and the ever-complicated dance of modern romance. Admittedly, I saw the tropes coming—but they didn’t play out in the way I’d expected.
At the heart of the story is Girlie, a character I found utterly captivating. She’s not just another trope but a wonderfully complex BDE (Big Dick Energy) figure whose refusal to conform is rooted in her childhood trauma. Watching her navigate relationships—often arms-lengthing people—was like peeling back layers of a vivid, intriguing onion. Girlie’s sharp knowledge of niche status symbols, like vintage watches, reveals her depth and the scars she carries. I was enthralled not just by her strength but by her vulnerabilities, making her feel authentically maladapted and achingly relatable.
William, her love interest, remains somewhat of an enigma, especially leading up to the book’s penultimate chapter. His character felt less fleshed-out than I would have hoped, yet it didn’t detract from the story’s powerful emotional landscape; in fact, it added to the allure. Their slow-burn romance felt thoughtful and unhurried, a refreshing change from the often frantic pace of contemporary love stories. At times, their chemistry was so understated it was almost like they were tiptoeing around their attraction, which resonated deeply with me. It mirrored real-life relationships, where timing and emotional readiness play a crucial role.
Hargrove’s writing style is polished yet deeply personal, elevating the narrative with a subtle grace that captures the essence of modern existence. The pacing, too, felt intentionally measured, allowing readers to savor the intricacies of Girlie’s world. It’s one of those novels that invites you to pause and reflect, much like the luxurious belongings that Girlie admires from a distance.
There were moments filled with poignant reflections that lingered long after I turned the last page. One such memorable moment captured the essence of self-acceptance amidst chaos, reminding me of the importance of honoring our journeys. These lines were so resonant, and I found myself highlighting numerous passages that spoke directly to my own experiences.
I usually read galleys with the urgency of someone trying to clear a towering TBR pile, yet Moderation felt like the perfect book at exactly the right time for me. It invited me to slow down, really absorb its themes, and revel in Girlie’s world. The understated luxury of the narrative made me pay attention and appreciate every detail.
I can wholeheartedly recommend Moderation to readers who enjoy character-driven stories with a touch of authenticity. If you appreciate books that dive into the complexities of modern love and the psychological effects of trauma in our connected yet isolating world, this one’s for you. It left me pondering my own relationships and the masks we wear—a mark of a truly impactful read. You might just find yourself revisiting Girlie and her world more than once, as I plan to do.
Thanks to NetGalley and the publisher for the ARC—I couldn’t be happier I took the plunge on this one!
Discover more about Moderation on GoodReads >>






