Book Review: From Under the Truck: A Memoir by Josh Brolin
As a devoted fan of memoirs, I often find myself diving into the lives of strangers, eagerly unearthing their stories and struggles. So, when I stumbled upon From Under the Truck: A Memoir by Josh Brolin, I felt a mix of excitement and trepidation. Would he be a fascinating storyteller, or would his journey leave me scratching my head? Spoiler alert: it did the latter more than the former!
From the very first moments of the audiobook, I found myself exclaiming "what the fuck" more times than I could count. My initial hope for an engaging, insightful experience quickly turned into astonishment and confusion as I navigated through this frankensteinish nightmare of a book. It’s bizarre to say this, but I left feeling like I know approximately the same amount about Josh Brolin as I did before picking it up—quite a feat for a memoir.
Brolin’s life story unfolds in fragmented snippets, blending poetry, monologues, and autobiography in ways that left me more bewildered than enlightened. Sure, the raw honesty of his struggles, particularly with his mother, may resonate on some level, but the overall execution felt chaotic and ill-conceived. The timeline bounces around with such ferocity that I nearly suffered narrative whiplash. And while I can appreciate a good dose of vulgarity in literature—believe me, life is messy and real—certain moments, like the visual of “having sex with couch cushions,” felt crass and unnecessary.
The chapter devoted to killing a sheep left me particularly flabbergasted. I spent significant time grappling with the emotional weight of his words, only to find there was no moral compass guiding the narrative. One genuinely interesting chapter might be immediately followed by a disjointed monologue that would have benefitted from more editorial guidance—which ultimately leaves the reader lost in a sea of unconnected thoughts.
Speaking of editorial guidance, one must wonder who let this project see the light of day. Memoirs can be intimate and revealing; they offer connections deeper than a mere recounting of events. If Brolin desires to explore poetry, then let him! But this amalgamation lacked the fluidity and poignancy that make memoirs resonate with readers.
Despite the missteps, there were glimpses of genuinely good content scattered throughout, which only added to my frustration. Had there been a clearer structure, or an overarching message, perhaps it could have evolved into a meaningful narrative. Instead, it felt like a collection of attempts at “realness” that ultimately fell flat, unable to leave a lasting impression.
In conclusion, From Under the Truck might cater to die-hard fans of Josh Brolin who are willing to overlook its many flaws for a glimpse into his chaotic world. However, for those seeking a profound literary experience—one that offers insight, sentiment, or humor—this memoir might leave you shaking your head in disbelief.
Many memoirs serve as windows into others’ lives; this one felt like a hall of mirrors—dizzily distorted and ultimately unsatisfying. As for me, I’ll remember this book as an impassioned one-star experience—one best approached with caution.
Discover more about From Under the Truck: A Memoir on GoodReads >>